Gay Canadian pastors optimistic Jamaica will be gay-friendly

Gay Canadian pastors optimistic Ja will repeal buggery law

BY INGRID BROWN Associate editor — special assignments

Sunday, December 02, 2012

Print this pageEmail A Friend!

VANCOUVER, Canada — Tim Stephenson is a former Canadian government minister, a current city councillor of Vancouver, and an ordained pastor, while Reverend Gary Paterson holds one of the highest positions in the United Church of Canada as its elected leader/moderator.

But the extensive political and religious accomplishments of both men are not what these two Canadians are most known for.

Reverend Gary Paterson (left) elected leader/moderator in the United Church of Canada sits with his partner Tim Stephenson; a politician and the first openly gay man to be ordained a church minister in Canada. The two, who have been legally married for most of the 33 years they have lived together, sat down at Vancouver City Hall to have a frank discussion with a Jamaica delegation last week.



In Stephenson’s case, it is the title of being the first openly gay man to be ordained a church minister in Canada, while for Paterson, it is the historic election of a gay man as moderator within this once ultra-conservative denomination.

The two, who have been legally married for the greater part of the 33 years and have lived together as partners, sat down at City Hall earlier last week to have a frank discussion with a Jamaica delegation of journalists and policymakers here in Vancouver participating in a knowledge exchange sesson organised by Panos Caribbean in partnership with Simon Fraser University and the Vancouver Initiative.

“We sometimes define ourselves as church and state sleeping together,” Stephenson quipped as he began the conversation.

He added further, “it took me 12 years to get ordained as a minister as the church wrestled with the issue”.

Both men have been previously married to women, with Paterson fathering three daughters from his union.

As a member of Canada’s New Democratic Party, Stephenson said he was elected as the first openly gay member of the legislature, then deputy speaker of the House, and subsequently cabinet minister, before his party lost power after a five-year stint in office.

Following this defeat, Stephenson said he returned to the church congregation to serve as minister before heading back to politics, this time to run for City Councillor 11 years ago. He has been re-elected four times, and was also appointed the Canadian representative to China.

Paterson had been ordained as the lead minister in the church before he disclosed his status as a gay man.

“The church struggled with me and Tim as ministers, although I was ordained when I was a married man,” he said.

Explaining the journey, Paterson said the United Church started to do educational work around homosexuality as far back as the 1980s, staging various workshops to help people get comfortable with the issue.

“In 1984, we produced the first report that there should be no contradiction between being Christian and gay,” he said, adding that there was extensive consultation done across Canada.

Out of this it was recommended that gay men and lesbians be allowed full membership in the church. Not everybody took the news with an open heart and mind, as about 10 per cent left the church. However, Paterson said, for the most part, the other 90 per cent were comfortable with the decision. Currently, 20 per cent of the church’s members are gay.

In the discussions that followed, Paterson said the evangelical church accused them of not being Christians, while the Catholics avoided the issue altogether.

Now, he says a large number of the church’s membership consists of “refugees” from evangelical churches; persons he said have been “damaged” by their old church’s beliefs.

“A lot of gay persons went to church because there is a belief that if you pray to Jesus you won’t be gay, but psychological studies prove there is just cessation of sex,” he said.

As such, Paterson said a part of his ministry is to reach out to people who have been badly damaged by the Christian church.

Turning to the biblical stance on homosexuality, Paterson said Jesus Christ never had anything to say about homosexuality, but had a lot to say about divorce and yet the church has been able to find ways to get around the dissolution of marriage.

“In fact, Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed because of the people’s inhospitality, and not because of the act of homosexuality,” he opined.

Questioned as to whether there is some truth to the statement that the gay community is becoming the most powerful and influential group on the planet Paterson dismissed the notion.

“That statement is ridiculous and comes from fear… sometimes gay people have influence and sometimes they don’t,” he said.

As a lawmaker, Stephenson was instrumental in allowing gay Canadian men to adopt children and to change the definition of the word ‘spouse’.

In fact, Paterson believes children raised by gay couples are stronger and more resilient, as they learn how to deal with differences and how to cope with bullying at school.

Paterson, who said he discovered his love for men from age 13, said he initially told his wife he was bisexual, but she was willing to give the relationship a chance.

“We had seven years of marriage, and when it ended we made a decision to share the parenting of the girls and not live more than 10 blocks away from each other,” he said.

Stephenson, who left his five-year marriage without fathering any children, said he quickly fit into the parenting role.

The men said they usually travel around the world on vacation as a couple and are looking forward to visiting Jamaica, although they have heard the stories that “it is a difficult place for gay people”.

They however expressed optimism that the Jamaican buggery laws will eventually be repealed.

“I think Jamaica will change its laws and things will get different,” Paterson said.

The couple say they have been invited to the United Church in Bermuda and are looking forward to sharing there.

Read more:


Montreal Gazette>Blogs >Montreal>Pop TartPop Tart RSS Feed

Award-winning doc on queer refugees fleeing to Canada screening for free on NFB website

December 7, 2012. 9:48 am • Section: Pop Tart

Award-winning doc on queer refugees fleeing to Canada screening for free on NFB website
Trudi, a lesbian from Jamaica who was “correctively” raped at gunpoint., is one of five refugees chronicled in Montreal filmmaker Paul Émile d’Entremont’s award-winning NFB documentary Last Chance. (All photos courtesy National Film Board of Canada)

Montreal filmmaker Paul Émile d’Entremont

Montreal filmmaker Paul Émile d’Entremont

Montreal filmmaker Paul Émile d’Entremont was directing another movie in Jordan some years ago when he came up with the idea to make his brand-new, award-winning documentary film Last Chance, which chronicles the struggles of five queer refugees from around the world – from some of the most rabidly anti-gay countries on the planet – seeking asylum in Canada.

“I felt compelled to make this movie because I am a gay man and was wondering what my next documentary should be and that would be important to me,” says d’Entremont. “My sexuality and being gay define everything that I am, so  while making this other film in Jordan, my DoP [director of photography] asked our driver if there were any gay people in Jordan and the cab driver replied, ‘No, there aren’t any.’ That reply was a trigger. I thought it would be interesting to make a film about gay Arabs. So I started hanging out with HELEM [in Montreal] and that led me to making this movie about gay refugees.”

Last Chance follows the heartrending journeys of Carlos, Jennifer (a transgender woman who was institutionalized by her own family), Zaki (who was thrown into an Egyptian jail), Alvaro and, lastly, Trudi, a lesbian from Jamaica who was “correctively” raped at gunpoint.

The doc took a decade to make, including three years of actually filming

“I wanted to follow individuals from their countries of origin as they flee to Canada,” d’Entremont  says. “That had never been done before.”

D’Entremont continues, “Trudi was the last story. I had been working with Jamaican activists in Toronto for two years. It wasn’t that there weren’t any stories – there was a list a mile long – but to identify someone who would participate in the doc and had a good chance of getting a visa, how do we do that? Trudi’s story was filmed the last year of this film.”


On a personal note, I think Last Chance is a poignant film. The film graphically portrays the issue of minority rights and exposes for the first time the ordeal that asylum seekers must go through, from their countries of origin to their arrival in Canada. It features such talking heads as renowned Montreal immigration and refugee lawyer Noel St. Pierre (whom I helped with a couple of LGBT asylum cases in the late 1990s), and the film’s closing scene brought me to tears.

“We struggled with the last scene, about whether it would send the right message,” d’Entremont says.

As for Canada’s refugee system, what is d’Entremont’s prognosis? Is Canada still the planet’s great big hope, or are we closing our borders?

“I’m no expert but I certainly have consulted a lot of experts and I agree with what I hear, that we have a one of the best systems in the world for refugee protection,” says d’Entremont, pointing out there are flaws in the system. “It is also under tremendous pressure and threat. We really don’t’ know how the [new reforms] voted  on in June will pan out. They have not really taken effect. So the jury is still out.”

Last Chance will be available for viewing for free online December 7-8-9 

Subsequently the film will be available for download-to-own, for $14.95 in high definition and $9.95 in standard definition, and as a video-on-demand rental for $2.95

Leave a Reply